To pool or not to pool?

Talent Pools - to pool or not too pool

Talent Pools – to pool or not too pool

I’ve recently had two debates on the topic of talent pools. One was a company that fervently believed in talent pools and had over 25,000 people in their pool, yet were struggling to fill their roles fast enough. The other was a company that was fervently against the concept, believing that they are a mystical silver bullet.

The concept of talent pools was created as a counterfoil for both hard to fill and fast to fill roles and are considered a pretty core tool for proactive recruiting solutions. I used them when I was a headhunter in capital markets in London – albeit before technology it was just ‘the black book’ (showing my age, I know!)

But today we seem to have talent pools for everything from contact centres to CEOs and everything in between.

So what is the definition of a talent pool?
• What’s the difference between a pool and a community?
• Which job families are pools appropriate for and which ones are not?
• What size should a pool be and how do you manage them?
• When they fail, why is that?

Where do you sit on this?

What are the pros and cons of talent pooling today?

Keep Reading...


It’s the 50th county I’ve spent time in and I was pondering on my way over how I was feeling about that. It’s been a